Outcome: Denied / dismissed
-
Preliminary decision: Taylor v. Holt
Complaint related to odour, noise, and flies from a livestock shelter and pen for goats. Complaint dismissed as respondent was not operating a farm business under the FPPA.
-
Procedural decision: Kelpin v. British Columbia Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals
Procedural decision regarding an adjournment request for a hearing on the seizure of four horses in Langley. The request was denied due to scheduling conflicts and the need to minimize costs and ensure timely resolution in the best interests of the animals.
-
Preliminary decision: Harvey v. HS Jansen and Sons Ltd.
Complaint related to manure management practices of a nearby dairy farm in Armstrong. Request for recusal of panel member due to alleged bias based on past employment with farm organizations.
-
Dismissal: Prokam Enterprises Ltd. v British Columbia Vegetable Marketing Commission
Appeal of BCVMC’s decision to deny a delivery allocation transfer to multiple transferees. The appellant was a proposed transferee but was excluded after the transferor chose to transfer its entire allocation to another party. The decision was related to BCVMC’s January 14, 2015 denial of the original transfer application.
-
Preliminary decision: Shawlee v. Quails’ Gate Okanagan Valley
Complaint related to noise from events held at a winery, including weddings, concerts, and other activities. Complaint dismissed as the activities did not constitute a farm operation under the FPPA.
-
Decision: Mountain Valley Dairy Ltd. v. British Columbia Milk Marketing Board
Appeal of BCMMB’s refusal to reconsider Mountain Valley’s licensing and pricing structure. Mountain Valley Dairy Ltd. argued for a new license class to support small on-farm niche processors, citing challenges in the current regulatory framework. The decision was related to the BCMMB’s Consolidated Order and the 2005 Specialty Review.
-
Decision: Flamingo Foods Ltd. v. BC Milk Marketing Board
Appeal of BCMMB’s enforcement decision to require immediate payment plus interest based on audit findings. The appellant disputes the accuracy of the audit, which concluded it underpaid for enriched milk used in specialty cheese production under the Domestic Dairy Product Innovation Program. The decision was related to Milk Board Orders 38(2) and 39(5).
-
Decision: E.M. v. British Columbia Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals
Appeal of seizure and costs regarding 1 dog and 4 cats due to unsanitary living conditions, untreated medical issues including severe ear mites, fleas, roundworm infestation and upper respiratory infections, and malnutrition. The appellant had a history of past seizures by the BC SPCA.
-
Preliminary decision: Barkwill v. Lychowyd and Cockrill
Complaint related to dust from haying and noise from tractor, weed whipper, and chainsaw use. Complaint dismissed as trivial, frivolous, vexatious and not made in good faith.
-
Decision: McLeod v. British Columbia Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals
Appeal of seizure regarding 96 cattle in Quesnel due to inadequate food, water, and shelter, lack of veterinary care, and poor herd management. The cattle exhibited severe malnutrition, frostbite, and other health issues.