Outcome: Partially approved
-
Decision: Binnersley v. British Columbia Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals
Appeal of seizure regarding one dog in Campbell River due to untreated medical issues including a dislocated hip, muscle atrophy, and pain following an accident.
-
Decision: Reid v. British Columbia Broiler Hatching Egg Commission
Appeal directed by the Supreme Court of British Columbia regarding the appellant’s entitlement to future quota issuance, entitlement to costs, and distribution of the court’s reasons to other producers.
-
Conditional Approval: BCFIRB to B.C. Chicken Marketing Board — Designation of Berryhill Foods Inc. as an Agency
BCFIRB conditionally approves the BCCMB’s recommendation to designate Berryhill Foods Inc. as an agency. Final approval is contingent upon meeting specified conditions, including finalizing agency terms, confirming compliance, developing contingency plans, and notifying growers.
-
Preliminary Decision: BC Vegetable Greenhouse I, L.P. v. British Columbia Vegetable Marketing Commission
Appeal of VMC’s Order 10/03(a) requiring BC Vegetable to remit $376,642 in levies. This preliminary decision addresses disclosure disputes, requests for forensic examination of Commission computers, scope of the appeal, and scheduling. The Board ordered limited further disclosure, dismissed other requests, and confined the appeal to levy calculation issues.
-
Costs decision: BC Vegetable Greenhouse I, L.P. v. British Columbia Vegetable Marketing Commission
Costs decision arising from appeal of BCVMC Order 10/03(a) regarding levy calculations for greenhouse vegetable producers. The matter involves costs applications by the BCVMC and BC Hot House Foods Inc. following extensive interlocutory steps and disputes over the scope of appeal and document disclosure.
-
Preliminary Decision: BC Vegetable Greenhouse I, L.P. v. British Columbia Vegetable Marketing Commission
Appeal of BCVMC’s Order 10/03(a) requiring BC Vegetable Greenhouse I, L.P. to remit $376,642 in outstanding levies. The BCVMC and BC Hot House sought summary dismissal of the appeal. The Board dismissed most grounds as frivolous or an abuse of process, but allowed the appeal to proceed on jurisdiction and computation issues.
-
Decision: Baran and Baran v. Roberts
Complaint related to dust and pest infestations, including flies and rodents, from a poultry farm in Aldergrove.
-
Decision: Baran v. Country Drive Poultry Farm Ltd., and Roberts
Complaint related to rodents, flies, manure spreading, dumping of rotten eggs, mortality disposal, and dust from a poultry farm in Aldergrove.
-
Decision: BCFIRB to BCVMC — Conditional designation of Village Fresh Canada ULC
Decision on the B.C. Vegetable Marketing Commission’s request to approve its conditional designation of Village Fresh Canada ULC as an agency, following a corporate restructuring that occurred without approval.
-
Decision: Arnold v. British Columbia Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals
Appeal of the BC SPCA’s seizure of the three birds and two dogs.