Outcome: Denied / dismissed
-
Decision: Hayden and Kemp v. Island Sea Farms Inc.
Complaint related to noise, odour and debris from a shellfish harvesting operation on Cortes Island.
-
Decision: J&E Egg Farm v. British Columbia Egg Marketing Board
Appeal of BCEMB’s summary dismissal decision to proceed to a full hearing. J&E Egg Farm’s request for exemption from the 75% self-marketing requirement and inclusion of Free Bird Organic sales. The decision was related to BCEMB’s Consolidated Orders.
-
Preliminary decision: Dragland v. Zdralek
Complaint related to noise from barking dogs on a neighbouring farm in West Kelowna. Complaint dismissed as the barking was not part of a farm operation under the FPPA.
-
Preliminary decision: Church/Jauselon & Bird v. Cusheon Lake Farm
Complaint related to noise from barking dogs at Cusheon Lake Farm. Complaint dismissed due to the death of the dog identified as the primary cause of disturbance.
-
Decision: Bilski v. British Columbia Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals
Appeal of seizure regarding one dog in Chilliwack due to inadequate shelter, unsanitary living conditions, and lack of exercise. The dog was kept in a car filled with debris and lacked proper care, including untreated medical issues such as a cut on its leg.
-
Decision: Skye Hi Farms Inc., Casey Van Ginkel DBA V3 Farms and Wilhelm Friesen & Lillian Fehr DBA W. Friesen Enterprises v British Columbia Broiler Hatching Egg Commission
Appeal of BCBHEC’s regulatory decision to enact Amending Order 11 and allot quota under the Regularization of Historically Non-compliant Silkie and Taiwanese Producers Program. Appellants argued the program failed to provide sufficient quota, undermined existing businesses, and was procedurally flawed.
-
Decision: Baker and Lemure v. British Columbia Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals
Appeal of seizure regarding 13 cats in Port Coquitlam due to inadequate shelter and space while appellants were homeless. The cats were kept in a homemade mobile shelter.
-
Decision: teBrinke d.b.a. Mountainview Acres v. British Columbia Chicken Marketing Board
Appeal of BCCMB’s decision to impose an overmarketing levy and license suspension for period A-136.
-
Decision: Nancy Leduc v. British Columbia Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals
Appeal of seizure and costs regarding two horses in Hazelton due to conditions including inadequate nutrition, lack of proper shelter, and insufficient veterinary care. The horses exhibited severe muscle wasting and were not protected from excessive cold.
-
Preliminary decision: Moran v. Kato’s Nursery (2007) Ltd.
Complaint related to water drainage issues caused by a nursery. Complaint dismissed as circumstances materially changed and no written submission was provided by the complainant.