Outcome: Deferred
-
Procedural decision: Prokam Enterprises Ltd. v. British Columbia Vegetable Marketing Commission
Procedural decision regarding an appeal of BCVMC’s reconsideration decision by Prokam Enterprises Ltd. The appeal concerns issues related to Prokam’s licence class and an interim order for storage crops marketing. The appeal was deferred pending the conclusion of a 2021 supervisory review addressing allegations of bad faith and unlawful conduct.
-
Procedural decision: Primary Poultry Processors Association of British Columbia v. British Columbia Chicken Marketing Board
An appeal of BCCMB pricing order #162 is deferred to be addressed by a supervisory panel as part of a supervisory review. The PPPABC can proceed with this and other deferred appeals after the supervisory process is completed.
-
Preliminary decision: Primary Poultry Processors Association of British Columbia / B.C. Chicken Growers’ Association v. British Columbia Broiler Hatching Egg Commission
Appeal of BCBHEC’s decision to remove revenues from spent fowl and salvage eggs from the cost of production calculations. The appellants opposed the deferral of their appeals, arguing against the BCBHEC’s unilateral changes to the price linkage formula. The decision was related to the price linkage agreement between the BCBHEC and the BCCMB.
-
Decision: BCFIRB to Prokam Enterprises Ltd. — Decision on Appeal Deferral and Supervisory Review
BCFIRB informs Prokam Enterprises Ltd. of the decision to defer its appeal pending the completion of the Vegetable Industry Supervisory Review. The letter outlines the supervisory panel’s interim decisions addressing Prokam’s urgent business concerns for the 2020/21 production year.
-
Letter: BCFIRB to PPPABC, BCCGA, BCBHEC — Deferral of appeals on price linkage pending supervisory review
BCFIRB grants BCBHEC’s request to defer two appeals concerning changes to the price linkage formula, pending a broader supervisory review on chicken supply chain pricing.
-
Decision: CFP Marketing Corporation v. British Columbia Vegetable Marketing Commission
Appeal of BCVMC’s decision to defer CFP’s agency application pending strategic and agency reviews. CFP argues procedural unfairness and seeks timely consideration. The decision was related to the BCVMC’s General Orders and the strategic planning process.
-
Procedural decision: Prokam Enterprises Ltd. v. British Columbia Vegetable Marketing Commission (Duplicate)
Appeal of BCVMC’s decision to defer further consideration of Prokam’s appeal. Prokam’s concerns about delay and request for interim relief were noted.
-
Decision: BCFIRB — Deferral of appeals on BC Hatching Egg Commission’s Exclusion Permit Program
BCFIRB defers consideration of appeals challenging the BCBHEC’s decision on the Exclusion Permit Program until the supervisory review process is completed.
-
Preliminary decision: Harrison v. Jaeger
Complaint related to noise from a barking dog on a sheep farm in Grand Forks.
-
Preliminary decision: Ruck and Tuovila v. Deleurme
Complaint related to odour from manure management and mortality disposal at a neighbouring feedlot. Complaint was referred to hearing.