Category: Regulated marketing appeal
-
Decision: Alverez et al. v. British Columbia Milk Marketing Board
Appeal of the BCMMB’s decision to refuse restoration of licenses and quotas, and to grant MSQ to appellants. The appellants challenged the refusal to restore licenses and fluid quotas, and the denial of MSQ allocation, related to milk production and quota management.
-
Procedural Decision: Northern Interior Dairyman’s Association and Mainland Dairymen’s Association v. British Columbia Milk Marketing Board
The procedural decision consolidates appeals against the BCMMB’s decision on freight rates.
-
Decision: Materi v. British Columbia Egg Marketing Board
Summary dismissal of appeal of BCEMB’s decision to revoke Materi’s layer quota allotment of 500 birds. Materi argued that the BCEMB’s seizure of over-quota birds prevented him from using his quota.
-
Decision: Materi v. British Columbia Egg Marketing Board
Appeal of BCEMB’s decision to revoke Materi’s layer quota allotment. The appellant alleged a mistake in the Summary Dismissal Decision and requested reconsideration under Rule 22. Panel declined to correct or clarify under Rule 22 (no clerical or jurisdictional error); held reconsideration improper and panel functionally exhausted.
-
Procedural decision: Lilydale Foods Ltd. v. British Columbia Chicken Marketing Board
The BCMB issues a decision regarding Lilydale Foods Ltd.’s appeal against the BCCMB’s decisions on grower payments, directing document production and setting timelines for both parties.
-
Preliminary decision: Lilydale Co-Operative Ltd. et al. v. B.C. Chicken Marketing Board
BCFIRB issues a decision on appeals regarding the BCCMB’s direction of product, addressing jurisdictional authority and marketing policy. The decision dismisses jurisdictional and implementation appeals but defers policy issues related to assurance of supply for further hearings.
-
Preliminary decision: British Columbia Chicken Growers’ Association v. British Columbia Chicken Marketing Board
BCFIRB denies a request from the BCCMB and processors to consolidate the B.C. Chicken Growers Association’s (BCCGA) appeal against the new General Orders (specifically Part 7, Assurance of Supply) with the upcoming Redirection Appeals.
-
Preliminary decision: Lilydale Co-Operative Ltd. et al. v. B.C Chicken Marketing Board
BCFIRB directs Lilydale Co-operative Ltd. to produce documents related to its usage of temporary import quota during the Avian Influenza crisis for appeals against BCCMB’s product redirection decisions.
-
Decision: Lilydale Co-Operative Ltd. et al. v. B.C. Chicken Marketing Board
BCFIRB dismisses appeals against Parts 7 and 8 of the BCCMB General Orders, which assure supply to processors based on historical market share and regulate new processor entrants. The decision supports maintaining industry stability and growth under current market conditions.
-
Procedural decision: Ladybug Manor v. British Columbia Turkey Marketing Board
BCFIRB grants an extension for Ladybug Manor to file its appeal against a BCTMB decision that cancelled its broker license.